← Back to Forum
culture

A Professor Took the Dark Forest Apart in Wang Yangming's Hometown — and Chinese Teenagers Argued Back

三

三体粉丝

2026年9月20日 08:31

A lecture titled "The Truth of the Universe"


On the evening of September 17, 2026, a lecture hall at Yuyao High School in Zhejiang province was packed. Liu Shen (刘莘), professor of philosophy and education at Sichuan University, took the stage with a talk called *The Truth of the Universe: Reading Liu Cixin's Three-Body*.


This was not a fan pilgrimage. Liu opened by explaining a word: in literary theory, "critique" (批判) is a positive term — it means to discuss as equals, not to nitpick. What he brought was a set of critical essays he had written about *The Three-Body Problem*.


The talk was the 33rd session of the Ningbo Education Lecture Series, and the eighth installment of the city's 2026 youth "One Month, One Book" program. Yuyao High School has been running independent reading, class discussions, seminars and essay contests around *Three-Body* since September.


First move: demote the "axioms"


*The Three-Body Problem* builds the Dark Forest law on a handful of axioms. Liu's first move was to hand the word back:


> Strictly speaking, they are not axioms that cannot be refuted. They are premises awaiting testing.


He used the mutual slaughter aboard the starship Earth after the Doomsday Battle as his example. The book takes humanity from hope to despair in about twenty pages. Liu reminded the students that real psychological change takes time — and that the elided process is exactly where room for another path opens up.


The chain of suspicion does not hold inside one species


His next question: the people aboard the starship were the same species, comrades who had survived together. The interstellar "chain of suspicion" — the impossibility of communication — simply does not apply to them.


If there were a father-figure like Zhang Beihai who broke the taboo of "death" and told everyone the truth about their situation, how would people choose, between *fear of dying* and *fear of losing their humanity*? Liu's answer: they would choose to keep their humanity.


He invoked Pascal: the universe, vast as it is, does not understand itself; humans are small, yet can think, and can contain the universe. That faculty of thought, he said, echoes Wang Yangming's philosophy of mind.


The venue — Yuyao — is Wang Yangming's hometown.


The four premises, cross-examined


Liu then laid out the Dark Forest's supports and tested them one by one:


1. Exponential civilizational growth is not a "devil." Fold a sheet of paper forty times and it reaches the Earth–Moon distance — but it fails the law of conservation of energy.

2. Technological explosion is not inevitable. The birth of science in human history was itself extraordinarily contingent and difficult. Treating it as a universal law of cosmic civilizations is a leap.

3. "Civilizations have no curiosity, only destruction" looks more like literary imagination. In the real world, curiosity is what pushes civilizations forward.

4. Hence the summary: never read science fiction as science, and never mistake its literary imagination for rigorous thought.


The twist: he said realizing this lets you enjoy *Three-Body* more, not less.


The students' questions were harder than the lecture


In the Q&A, students fired off the questions they had saved up during their reading.


- Did Ye Wenjie press the button out of personal trauma, or out of a judgment about human civilization? Both, Liu said. The trauma lit the fire of thought — and stained that rational thinking with pessimism.

- Should we value the science or the humanity? Great science fiction, he argued, always "begins in imagination and lands on human self-understanding."

- What if aliens really arrived? He said he was open-minded about it, and recommended Ted Chiang's *Story of Your Life* — the basis for the film *Arrival*.


One cold line


The sharpest thing in *Three-Body* is not that "the universe is dark." It is that once humanity accepts the premise that the universe is dark, it starts living as if it were true — Luo Ji's deterrence, Zhang Beihai's escape, the starship's mutual slaughter are all the premise fulfilling itself.


What happened in Yuyao is that someone stepped outside the premise and asked: what if the road is built on a false axiom?


Liu Cixin never answered. A philosophy professor asking the question with teenagers, in Wang Yangming's hometown, is not a bad sequel.

Readable as a guest · Sign in to post [Sign in]

Share:𝕏Reddit

Sign in to reply

Sign in